Introduction
The annual Union Budget presentation is undoubtedly one of the most important parliamentary events in India. As the government lays out its economic agenda and planned fiscal policies for the coming year, the budget session provides a pivotal opportunity to shape the country's development trajectory. With India now the world's fifth largest economy and poised to continue its ascent, the policy choices made hold significance not just domestically but globally.
As Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman rises in Parliament to present Budget 2024-25, the economic context she must navigate is challenging yet hopeful. Having displayed remarkable resilience in recovering from the COVID-19 shock, India once again faces turbulence arising from global headwinds. Inflation remains elevated, requiring delicate handling of fiscal and monetary policies. However, if prudence and care for the common citizen is prioritized, India can thrive in the post-pandemic era through stable, sustainable and inclusive growth.
Promoting Fiscal Discipline
A central theme for Budget 2024-25 must be promoting responsible fiscal discipline. This is imperative today given rising inflationary pressures and the risk of macroeconomic imbalances. Fiscal profligacy can quickly spiral into higher prices, falling rupee, widening current account deficit and lower investor confidence. However, fiscal consolidation policies must be just, equitable and not choke off economic recovery.
Assessing India's Fiscal Trajectory
Over the past decade, India's fiscal deficit has ranged between 6-7% of GDP, higher than the target of 3%. While COVID necessitated additional spending, deficits are projected to fall to 5% by 2025. Central government debt is around 90% of GDP. However, India's debt profile is seen as sustainable by rating agencies, given high domestic ownership. Low tax to GDP ratio of about 17% constrains fiscal space.
Implications of High Deficits and Debt
Persistently high fiscal deficits have implications like inflation, external imbalances, higher interest costs crowding out private investment and limiting development spending. Hence, a measured glide path for deficit reduction is needed. However, drastic austerity or spending cuts can derail growth. The key is judicious, transparent fiscal policies focused on quality of spending and boosting revenues.
Approaches for Responsible Fiscal Consolidation
The budget must outline a prudent fiscal consolidation roadmap. Priority areas could include:
- Rationalizing subsidies, especially fuel and food, and channeling savings to productive capital spending
- Widening tax base and improving compliance, without increasing tax rates. Bringing more services under GST.
- Asset monetization program to unlock value from public sector assets
- Boosting tax revenue growth by sustaining economic momentum
- Continuing reforms in areas like GST, direct benefit transfers to improve efficiency
- Transparent accounting, limiting off-budget expenditures and strengthening audits
Thus a balanced approach limiting wasteful expenses, improving compliance and asset utilization while supporting growth-focused expenditures is required. Open debate on priorities and trade-offs is essential for public buy-in.
The budget session is the right forum for the government to signal its commitment to fiscal discipline and transparency. While economic growth cannot be sacrificed, prudent policies aligned with social justice can steady India's fiscal ship and set the stage for inclusive development.
Here is Part II of the essay developed in full length on "Banking Reforms for Financial Inclusion":
Financial inclusion has made significant strides in India, yet gaps remain in extending banking access equitably. Prudent banking reforms must balance innovation with stability to sustain an enabling financial ecosystem.
Progress on Financial Inclusion
India has made noteworthy progress on financial inclusion, with bank account ownership rising from 35% in 2011 to 80% in 2021. Jan Dhan Yojana added over 400 million accounts. RBI’s licensing of small finance and payments banks has expanded last-mile access. The India Stack ecosystem has enabled paperless, presence-less banking. Aadhar, UPI, RuPay and other platforms are bringing millions into formal financial systems.
However, gaps in access remain, especially in rural areas where availability of bank branches is lower. Account ownership among women also lags at 77% compared to 83% for men. So further strengthening the breadth and depth of financial access is vital.
Challenges Facing India’s Banking Sector
While laudable in many ways, India’s banking sector faces considerable stresses. Gross non-performing assets ratio stands at 7.3% as of September 2022. Repeated governance lapses reveal deficiencies in oversight and risk management, be it at private banks like ICICI and Yes Bank or public sector ones like PNB. Undercapitalization also constrains the ability of public sector banks to expand lending.
Proposed Interventions
To place India’s banking system on a sustainable path aligned with equity, various policy measures can be considered:
- Expanding access by leveraging postal bank networks, mobile money and decentralized local institutions as banking correspondents
- Allowing more flexible interest rate-setting to improve transmission of monetary policy
- Implementing a robust governance framework for public sector banks with greater autonomy
- Recapitalizing banks through transparent programs like the Bank Investment Company
- Using Fintech to expand affordable credit through digital platforms and big data analytics
- Building financial literacy to promote responsible borrowing and lending
There are merits in exploring centralized monitoring of bank accounts through a common platform to detect suspicious transactions and improve oversight. However, consent, data protection and accountability safeguards would need to be robust. Overall, a balanced approach expanding access while safeguarding stability is needed.
India’s banking system has served as the bedrock of its growing economy. With prudent regulation evolved through democratic processes, it can continue to empower millions more equitably and sustainably. The budget session should outline reforms that balance innovation with stability, promoting financial discipline and justice.
Here is Part III of the essay developed in full on "Investing in Human Development":
While rapid economic growth is vital, ultimately human development must be the end goal. Budget 2024-25 is an opportune time to prioritize policies that equip India’s people with health, knowledge and skills to lead productive lives with dignity.
India’s Demographic Edge
With 65% of its population below 35, India enjoys tremendous demographic potential. By 2025, the average Indian will be just 29 years old, making it one of the world's youngest nations. This offers a unique edge, with the working age population supporting economic expansion. But this edge can only be leveraged if people have access to quality healthcare, education, skills and employment.
Gaps in Human Development
Despite progress, India continues to underperform on human development metrics:
- Maternal mortality rate is 145 per 100,000 births, compared to just 5 in OECD countries
- Stunting affects 35% of children under 5, contributing to learning deficits
- Adult literacy rate is only around 77%
- Only 50% of India's graduates are considered employable
- Workforce lacks modern technical skills and critical thinking abilities
Boosting Public Investment
To tap India's human capital potential, Budget 2024-25 must prioritize:
- Expanding health coverage through insurance schemes like Ayushman Bharat
- Mission POSHAN 2.0 to alleviate malnutrition and stunting
- Strengthening primary healthcare infrastructure and access to generic drugs
- Progressive universalization of quality secondary education and skills programs
- Public-private partnerships for vocational training aligned to industry needs
- Hiring additional teachers and building schools with modern facilities
- Digitizing education and leveraging technology for hybrid learning
Providing market-relevant education and healthcare will be transformative investments reaping rich dividends over time. With the right foundation, India's youth can drive sustainable and equitable growth.
Here is Part IV of the essay developed in full on "Towards Mindful and Inclusive Development":
Economic metrics like GDP growth capture only material aspects of progress. As India aims for prosperity, budget policies must also cultivate mindful, compassionate and holistic development that uplifts all sections.
The Need for Inclusive Growth
While India's economy has expanded substantially since liberalization, inequality remains a concern. The Gini coefficient stands at 35, comparable to many sub-Saharan African nations. Regional disparities between urban and rural areas persist. Poverty ratios are higher among women, SCs, STs and minorities.
To be meaningful, growth must be inclusive and shared. Budget 2024-25 can promote equity through:
- Urban and rural infrastructure investment creating opportunities across India
- Financial inclusion programs targeting unbanked regions and populations
- Skilling initiatives focused on marginalized communities
- Enhanced allocations for health, education and social security access
- Support for marginal farmers, MSMEs and informal sector workers
- Policies promoting renewable energy, clean air and water - key for vulnerable groups
- Governance reforms to ensure just, transparent and efficient delivery of services
Cultivating Mindfulness and Well-being
Alongside material progress, India must nurture values of compassion, moderation and equanimity. To this end, budget policies could:
- Support mindfulness programs teaching yoga, meditation, life skills
- Integrate lessons on ethics and philosophy in education curricula
- Train mental health professionals using indigenous techniques like Ayurveda
- Develop happiness and well-being indices going beyond economic measures
- Promote community values of sharing and volunteering
- Propagate sustainable living models rooted in Indian wisdom traditions
With prudent policies furthering economic justice and societal mindfulness, India can achieve holistic development benefiting all citizens. This will set a progressive example for the world.
"Towards Mindful and Inclusive Development":
Economic metrics like GDP growth capture only material aspects of progress. As India aims for prosperity, budget policies must also cultivate mindful, compassionate and holistic development that uplifts all sections.
The Need for Inclusive Growth
While India's economy has expanded substantially since liberalization, inequality remains a concern. The Gini coefficient stands at 35, comparable to many sub-Saharan African nations. Regional disparities between urban and rural areas persist. Poverty ratios are higher among women, SCs, STs and minorities.
To be meaningful, growth must be inclusive and shared. Budget 2024-25 can promote equity through:
- Urban and rural infrastructure investment creating opportunities across India
- Financial inclusion programs targeting unbanked regions and populations
- Skilling initiatives focused on marginalized communities
- Enhanced allocations for health, education and social security access
- Support for marginal farmers, MSMEs and informal sector workers
- Policies promoting renewable energy, clean air and water - key for vulnerable groups
- Governance reforms to ensure just, transparent and efficient delivery of services
Cultivating Mindfulness and Well-being
Alongside material progress, India must nurture values of compassion, moderation and equanimity. To this end, budget policies could:
- Support mindfulness programs teaching yoga, meditation, life skills
- Integrate lessons on ethics and philosophy in education curricula
- Train mental health professionals using indigenous techniques like Ayurveda
- Develop happiness and well-being indices going beyond economic measures
- Promote community values of sharing and volunteering
- Propagate sustainable living models rooted in Indian wisdom traditions
With prudent policies furthering economic justice and societal mindfulness, India can achieve holistic development benefiting all citizens. This will set a progressive example for the world.
Part V Reforming the Stock Market and Financial Sector":
India’s stock markets have seen rapid growth, reaching market capitalization of over $3 trillion in 2022. However, for the common investor, thePlaying a crucial role in capital formation and corporate growth, India’s stock markets have expanded rapidly, reaching a market capitalization of over $3 trillion in 2022. However, for the everyday retail investor, the markets can seem more like a casino than an engine for equitable growth. Prudent regulation balancing flexibility with stability can make the markets work better for shared prosperity.
Key Issues in Stock Markets
Some issues that plague India’s stock markets include:
- Speculative trading and excessive volatility that confuses retail investors
- Governance concerns around insider trading and lack of transparency
- Inadequate monitoring that enables share price manipulation
- High concentration among a few stocks distortion allocation away from small firms
- Limited SME listings, hampering their access to capital
Potential Reform Areas
To build vibrant yet stable capital markets, policymakers could explore:
- Tightening regulation around insider trading through digitized surveillance systems to detect irregularities
- Higher disclosure standards on corporate governance, finances and related-party transactions
- Curbing speculative derivative products that mainly benefit arbitrageurs
- Incentivizing long-term investors through pooled funds and improved tax treatment
- Relaxing SME listing requirements for greater formalization and access to equity
- Developing dedicated platforms/SME exchanges to broaden retail participation
- Leveraging technology for faster trade settlement and efficient monitoring
Equity markets must balance flexibility for companies with adequate protections and level playing field for investors. Aligned thus with India’s development needs, capital markets can enable equitable and sustainable economic expansion.
Here is Part VI of the essay developed in full length providing examples of "Successful Financial Inclusion Models":
While India can chart its own unique path to financial inclusion, global best practices provide valuable lessons. Studying successful models in other countries or institutional contexts can inform pragmatic policies tailored to local realities.
Case Study 1: Malaysia's Islamic Banking System
Malaysia has built a robust Islamic banking segment accounting for over a quarter of its banking assets. Steps taken include:
- Regulatory support for Islamic banking products in line with Sharia principles
- Tax neutrality between Islamic and conventional finance
- Sovereign sukuk issuances to build scale
- Macroprudential policies aligned with Islamic finance
- Governance frameworks tailored for Islamic banks
This facilitated greater financial access in a religiously diverse country while maintaining stability.
Case Study 2: Brazil's Bolsa Familia Program
Bolsa Familia provides cash transfers to low-income households conditional on children attending school and getting vaccinated. Outcomes:
- Reduced poverty and income inequality
- Improved health and education indicators among recipients
- Administered efficiently through biometrics-linked national ID cards
- Political buy-in across party lines
The program demonstrates how targeted cash transfers can promote inclusion.
Case Study 3: Self-Help Groups (SHGs) in India
SHGs are typically 10-20 member women's groups that pool savings into a common fund for lending within the group. Key benefits:
- Bottom-up approach building financial literacy
- Access to microcredit and savings without dependence on external lenders
- Focus on rural women's empowerment
- Community-based model enabling cooperative development
SHGs exemplify how grassroots collective action can successfully drive financial inclusion with women leaders.
Studying global and local models offers insights into policies that balance innovation with social justice and stability when pursuing inclusive growth.
Here is Part VII of the essay developed in full length on "The Path Forward: An Agenda for an Inclusive, Mindful India":
As India approaches the 75th year of Independence, the economy stands at an inflection point. With prudent policies prioritizing stability, sustainability and social justice, India can make the next 25 years the most transformational yet.
Seizing India's Opportunities
The Indian economy has shown remarkable resilience, retaining its position as the world's fastest growing major economy even in the face of global headwinds. Key advantages that can catalyze sustainable development include:
- Demographic dividend of a young, working-age population
- Expanding middle class and domestic consumption
- Increasing integration with global value chains
- Vibrant technology and start-up ecosystems
- Natural resources that can aid renewable energy sufficiency
Budget 2024-25 offers the chance to unleash these opportunities through investments in human capital and infrastructure.
Priority Areas for Public Investment
Specific sectors requiring focus include:
- Universal healthcare and nutrition security
- Progressive universalization of education
- Skills and employment generation
- Infrastructure - roads, ports, broadband connectivity
- Clean energy and sustainability practices
- Efficient, real-time delivery systems for public services
Holistic Development for Shared Prosperity
Equally important is cultivating an enabling environment based on ethics and Indianness:
- Grassroots democracy through empowered local governments
- Cooperatives and community-driven development
- Preserving pluralism, inclusion and social harmony
- Propagating mindfulness, compassion and moderation in society
- Environmentally sustainable production patterns
- Foreign policy enhancing mutual understanding across nations
Through prudent policies and collective efforts, India can become a globally respected leader, showing how shared prosperity and mindfulness can co-exist.
Here is Part VIII of the essay developed in full length on "The Role of Technology and Innovation":
Technology will undoubtedly be a key enabler for financial inclusion and broader national development goals. However, prudent policies are needed to leverage tech for empowerment rather than encroachment.
Expanding Digital Financial Access
Digital payments have already helped expand financial access efficiently in India. Further efforts could include:
- Enabling mobile and micro-ATM networks through regulatory support
- UPI integration across payment systems and merchant networks
- Digitized ID and eKYC for seamless, paperless account opening
- Big data analytics for credit risk modeling expanding lending
- Blockchain pilots for remittances and transactions
- Comprehensive cybersecurity and data protection frameworks
However, interoperability across systems and offline access options remain vital given the digital divide.
Emerging Technologies' Promise and Pitfalls
Innovations like AI, IoT, drones and biotech can transform service delivery across sectors like healthcare, agriculture and education. But ethical risks around data misuse, autonomy and job losses must be mitigated through regulation. Mass surveillance risks from centralized monitoring of accounts and transactions outweigh potential benefits.
India must chart its own approach to emerging tech, avoiding both hype and hysteria. The focus must remain on human-centric policies that empower rather than encroach.
Investing in Digital Infrastructure and Skills
To tap technology's potential, India must invest in both physical infrastructure like broadband and power, as well as human capital through STEM education, IT skills programs and digital literacy. This will enable inclusive innovation and participate in the Fourth Industrial Revolution.
With pragmatism and principle, technology can accelerate financial inclusion and equitable development. But prudent regulation is key to prevent excesses. Technology must assist humanity, not control it.
No comments:
Post a Comment